PERPETUALLYHAUNTED

The Pennsylvania collection

Pike County

12 places. A county full of stories.

Discover local legends, historic places and the stories of sites you can explore virtually.

Explore this county on the map →
Arrowhead’s shingled facade, green-trimmed porch and front walk under fresh snow in Milford.Outdoors

Arrowhead

Arrowhead, the Milford home associated with literary agent Virginia Kidd and science-fiction writer James Blish, also became home to a story about an…

The white, multi-story former Cliff Park Inn overlooks a lawn, with a covered porch and green shutters.Inns & businesses

Cliff Park Inn

Cliff Park Inn near Milford began as an 1820 Buchanan family farmhouse and became an inn in 1900. Its long hospitality history also produced stories…

The Dimmick Inn at the corner of Broad and East Harford streets in Milford.Inns & businesses

Dimmick Inn

The Dimmick Inn occupies the corner of Broad and Harford Streets in Milford. Samuel Dimmick established the original inn in 1828. After that wooden…

Aerial photograph of the lakeside ranch complex and riding ring on Foster Hill Road.Outdoors · Aerial view

Former Malibu Dude Ranch

Guests at the former Malibu Dude Ranch near Milford in Pike County shared several different accounts of unexpected company. In January 2009, a…

Aerial view of East High Street in Milford, with the large, many-gabled former Winsor Inn in the lower right.Schools · Aerial view

Former Winsor Inn and Judge School

The former Winsor Inn on East High Street in Milford began as a summer house. Chef Harold Winsor converted it into an inn in 1926, and the building…

The Harford-Smith House and neighboring buildings seen from above along East Harford Street.Historic homes

Harford-Smith House

The Harford-Smith House on East Harford Street is associated with Robert Harford, who is credited with building it around 1740. Later additions…

Roof and grounds of the historic Laurel Villa inn on the corner of Second and East Ann streets.Inns & businesses

La Posada

Laurel Villa stood at Second and Ann Streets in Milford, welcoming travelers from 1876 and serving for a time as a stagecoach stop. The Muhlhauser…

Red-and-white Milford marquee above the small theater’s brick and glass-block entrance.Inns & businesses

Milford Theater

At the Milford Theater on East Catherine Street, performers once kept a seat for former owner Thomas C. Pitney. A contemporary newspaper report…

The old Milford jail’s stone walls, cupola and fish-shaped weathervane at Broad and High streets.Institutions

Old Stone Courthouse and former Pike County Jail

Milford’s old Pike County jail is associated with Herman Paul Schultz, who was executed in December 1897 for murdering his wife, Lizzie. A later…

A two-lane road curves between guardrails and trees on the southern approach to Porters Lake.Outdoors

PA 402 south of Porters Lake

A woman carrying a lantern is said to walk Route 402 south of Porters Lake in Pike County. The tradition describes her wrapped in a shawl, the light…

Columned front of the Pike County Historical Society museum in Milford.Culture & landmarks

The Columns Museum

The Columns Museum in Milford holds belongings of philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce and his wife, Juliette. A room and adjoining hallway associated…

The Tom Quick Inn’s long white porch and upper gables framed by summer foliage on Broad Street.Inns & businesses

Tom Quick Inn

The Tom Quick Inn on Broad Street in Milford has accumulated ghost stories during its long life as a hotel. In 2005, Connections magazine recorded…